How to Avoid Making Biased Hiring Decisions
Posted by Jessica Miller-Merrell
One of the hardest things to let go of, in all aspects of life, are the biases we develop over time. It happens naturally through our experiences, interactions, and relationships and it is almost inevitable. Since we each have a unique way of looking at life in general, we also each form assumptions and judgments about other people, creating a filter that changes how we view those around us. While it is commonplace to form these kinds of biases, the accompanying filter doesn’t always paint a picture that is accurate.
This is especially true when it comes to your company’s hiring practices. All too often, hiring decisions are based on bias and how we view a candidate, rather than on facts, skills, and ability. It’s a sad fact that good candidates sometimes don’t pass the test because someone forms a negative impression within the first few minutes of meeting them. Some may argue that these impressions and judgments are actually their instincts kicking in, and they should be listened to. But in most cases, they are just judgments, plain and simple. To avoid making bad hiring decisions by letting bias creep in, follow these four tips.
Identify Your Biases
Some of the most common reasons that candidates are subjected to bias are superficial things like the clothing they’re wearing; the way they speak; their age, sex, or race; or a perceived lack of confidence or arrogance. The problem with using these characteristics to judge the quality of a candidate is that they either have no bearing on job performance, when it comes to things like age, sex, or race, or they are things that can’t be possibly be assessed as quickly as the judgment is made, such as when someone seems to be arrogant. When you identify the factors that tend to be stumbling blocks for you, it’s easier to avoid making that judgment or inquiring about the trait.
Get to Know The Candidate Ahead of Time
To avoid making snap judgments about candidates the first time you meet them, get to know them ahead of time. You can do this through phone interviews, online skill assessments, speaking to their references, or requiring pre-interview assignments. All of these activities provide a more comprehensive view of the candidate that would be hard to get from a one-time meeting in person. When you’re face to face, it’s hard not to judge even simple things like a handshake, eye contact, and nervousness. Taking the time to do some research will also create a more accurate first impression, and it will prevent having the entire interview be tainted by either a good or bad impression.
Focus on the Facts, Not Feelings
If you’ve done any amount of hiring, you’ve likely heard and probably said things like, “I feel, “I think,” “he/she is not a good fit,” or “he/she would be a good team player.” The problem with all of these phrases is that they focus on opinions and feelings, not facts. While there is something to be said for instincts, especially those that have been honed and sharpened through years of experience, our feelings and thoughts are often misread as instincts. Instead of basing your decisions on instincts, focus on quantitative and measurable information, such as accomplishments, skills, experience, and education. Ask questions about these elements, and give them more weight than what you may think or feel.
Give It Time
Even when highly-trained HR professionals conduct interviews, the hiring decision is often made within the first five minutes of meeting a candidate. The problem here is obvious, but it still happens time and time again. To avoid making the mistake of deciding whether or not to hire someone without even speaking in-depth with him or her, put the 30-minute rule into practice. Determine ahead of time that you won’t form a yes or no opinion until after you’ve spent 30 minutes with the candidate. You still may not be able to give a definitive answer at that time, but you’ll at least have put off making an uninformed decision.
What are your tips for avoiding bias in interviews? Let us know in the comments section below.
Talent Management – Strategies for Success
The fight for top talent is raging in the ranks of recruiters. It’s a competitive market, and if you’re not prepared, you may lose the war. Upgrade your staffing process with improved Talent Management Strategies.DOWNLOAD
Jessica is listed as the 2nd most influential recruiter online and as the 8th most powerful woman on Twitter. She is the author of Tweet This! Twitter for Business, a how-to business guide for Twitter users. She also writes for a number of leading publications, including Fortune, HR Magazine, SmartBrief, and HR Executive Magazine.
STAY IN TOUCH WITH US
Follow us on our social media channels for instant notifications on our latest articles.
Because accurate assessments mean the right person for the job, eSkill customizes each test to the question from a library of over 3,000 subjects and subtopics.
Recruiting Manager Zappos
“The wide variety and customizability of eSkill’s online testing allows us to pre-screen many of our candidates before they even get to our doors. And this is a key factor, because once a potential hire shows he/she possesses the skills necessary to do the job, our recruiters can concentrate on the second—and equally important—part of the [...]